Privatisation: What Would Happen If Private Companies Ran Indian Railways?

Synopsis: Allowing private companies to run Indian Railways could boost efficiency, modernize infrastructure, and enhance passenger experience through competition and innovation. Faster trains, cleaner coaches, and better services may emerge on major routes. However, full privatization is improbable due to the system’s vast scale, social responsibilities, and operational challenges.

Railways have long been the lifeline of India, connecting cities, towns, and villages while transporting millions of passengers and tonnes of freight every day. From historic steam engines to sleek semi-high-speed trains, the system has grown into one of the largest rail networks in the world. Yet, despite technological upgrades and modernization efforts, challenges like overcrowding, delays, and ageing infrastructure persist. What if private companies were allowed to run Indian Railways, could competition and innovation transform the way the nation travels?

History of Railways 

Indian Railways traces its origins to more than a century and a half ago. On 16 April 1853, India’s first passenger train made its historic journey from Bori Bunder in Bombay to Thane, covering just 34 kilometres. Pulled by three steam locomotives, Sahib, Sultan and Sindh. The train carried thirteen carriages and marked the beginning of rail travel in the country. Interestingly, a photograph often associated with this inaugural run actually shows a later train with a single locomotive, a detail that is commonly misunderstood but widely circulated.

The years that followed were defined by ambitious engineering feats and immense human effort. One of the earliest challenges was constructing a rail route across the Bhore Ghat to link Bombay with Poona. Built at an elevation of nearly 2,000 feet, the project involved tunnels, steep gradients and reverse viaducts, taking nine years to complete and coming at a heavy human cost. Around the same period, the first railway workshop was set up at Jamalpur in Bihar in 1862, which went on to become one of India’s earliest industrial hubs, housing foundries, rolling mills and large-scale manufacturing facilities.

As the network expanded, railways began shaping both geography and governance. Delhi Junction, established in 1864 near Chandni Chowk, became the northern region’s first major station and remains a critical junction even today. Landmark projects like the Pamban Bridge which was India’s first sea bridge, opened in 1914, demonstrated the growing technical sophistication of the system. 

Over time, Indian Railways also embraced modernisation, from launching its official website in 2000 and introducing online ticketing through IRCTC in 2002, to rolling out CNG-powered trains in 2015. Institutional changes followed as well, with the Railway Budget being merged with the Union Budget from 2017, signalling a new chapter in how the railways are governed.

Current Scenario

Today, Indian Railways operates one of the largest rail networks in the world under a single management, making it the backbone of long-distance passenger travel and bulk freight movement in the country. It remains the most energy-efficient and cost-effective mode of transport, and is the preferred carrier for automobiles across India. Over the past few years, the government has actively pushed investor-friendly reforms, opening up the sector to foreign direct investment for freight corridors, station redevelopment and high-speed rail. As a result, both domestic and global players are now lining up to participate in India’s rail expansion story.

Operationally, the scale of progress has been significant. By 2025, Indian Railways had expanded track length by nearly 35,000 kilometres, ramped up annual production to around 30,000 wagons and 1,500 locomotives, increased freight’s share to 29 percent, and reduced accidents by close to 80 percent. Semi-high-speed, self-propelled trains like Vande Bharat have reshaped passenger expectations with faster acceleration, reduced travel times and modern onboard features aligned with global standards. The ambition now goes beyond domestic use, with plans underway to export ‘Made in India’ Vande Bharat trainsets to markets in Europe, South America and East Asia by 2025-26.

Financially, Indian Railways is operating at an unprecedented scale. It recorded a record revenue of around Rs. 2.7 lakh crore in FY25, with passenger numbers crossing 7 billion and freight loading reaching over 1,600 MT. Passenger revenues surged on the back of higher volumes and premium train services, while freight earnings continued to climb steadily. Massive capital commitments underline the long-term vision, with over 430 infrastructure projects sanctioned, investments of nearly Rs. 16.7 lakh crore planned by 2031, and widespread upgrades in signalling, safety systems like KAVACH, station modernisation and electrification. Despite the scale and complexity, the system continues to prioritise affordability while steadily improving punctuality, safety and operational efficiency.

Private Companies Running Indian Railways

Imagine a scenario where private companies could fully participate in running Indian Railways, with multiple players bidding for entire corridors or regional networks under long-term concessions, say 20-30 years. Some companies could focus on building and managing stations, tracks, and signalling systems, investing in modern passenger amenities, digital ticketing, and faster train turnarounds. By taking responsibility for infrastructure, these players could modernize the network at a scale and speed that the current government budget often cannot support.

Meanwhile, separate private operators could bid to run the trains themselves on these corridors, managing schedules, rolling stock, pricing, and onboard services. Multiple operators could compete on the same routes, offering a range of services, from premium express trains with modern amenities to budget-friendly options for daily commuters. Competition could push companies to improve punctuality, enhance passenger experience, and introduce innovations like high-speed services, Wi-Fi, and modern seating, making train travel more efficient and comfortable.

Operationally, private operators could focus on high-frequency services on busy corridors, faster turnarounds at stations, and energy-efficient locomotives. Less profitable lines could be maintained through partnerships, revenue-sharing, or creative scheduling to ensure coverage while prioritizing quality on major routes. By separating infrastructure management from train operations, and allowing both to bid for long-term corridors, India could develop a competitive, passenger-focused rail ecosystem. 

In simple words, railways would operate much like the airline industry. Some companies build and manage the stations and tracks, just like Adani and GMR run airports, while other companies operate the trains themselves, similar to how airlines like Indigo or Air India run flights, together creating a network that is modern, efficient, and customer-centric. 

How This Could Affect Consumers

For passengers, the biggest advantage of private participation could be improved service quality and modern amenities. With multiple operators competing on the same routes, travelers might experience faster, more punctual trains, cleaner coaches, upgraded seating, and enhanced onboard features like Wi-Fi or entertainment. Premium express services could offer conveniences similar to business-class travel, while mid-range and budget options would provide more choices for different needs. Dynamic pricing could also help operators adjust to demand during holidays or peak seasons, ensuring better availability of seats.

At the same time, costs for travelers could go either way. Private operators might adopt more efficient, eco-friendly technologies by using energy-efficient locomotives, regenerative braking, or optimized operations that reduce overall travel costs and environmental impact. On the flip side, fares could rise on popular routes or premium services as companies seek profitability, and routes with lower demand could see higher ticket prices or fewer services. Travelers would need to weigh convenience and comfort against potentially higher costs in some cases.

Overall, a privatized rail system could deliver a more efficient, comfortable, and passenger-focused experience, but careful regulation would be essential to balance accessibility and profitability. Policies ensuring minimum service standards on lower-demand routes, standardized ticketing systems, and incentives for eco-friendly operations could help make modernization inclusive and affordable.

Why This Won’t Happen

While the idea of private companies running Indian Railways is intriguing, the scale and complexity of the system make full privatization highly improbable. With ~35,000 kilometres of track, 7 billion passengers annually, and thousands of trains and stations to manage, coordinating investment, operations, and safety across the entire network would be a massive challenge. Balancing modernization, efficiency, and affordability on such a scale is far beyond the capacity of any single private company or even a group of private operators.

Financial, social, and political factors add further barriers. Indian Railways is a public service, providing affordable transport to millions and employment to over a million workers nationwide. Private operators might prioritize profitability on high-demand routes, but less-traveled lines could see reduced services or higher fares, sparking resistance from passengers, unions, and policymakers. While selective private participation on specific corridors is feasible, fully privatizing India’s railways remains an unlikely and distant scenario.

Conclusion

In conclusion, allowing private companies to operate Indian Railways could bring speed, efficiency, and innovation to a system that serves millions every day. Competition might drive better services, cleaner coaches, and faster trains, transforming the passenger experience on busy routes. Yet, the sheer scale of the network, its social obligations, and the need for affordable travel make full privatization unlikely. 

Disclaimer: The views and investment tips expressed by investment experts/broking houses/rating agencies on tradebrains.in are their own, and not that of the website or its management. Investing in equities poses a risk of financial losses. Investors must therefore exercise due caution while investing or trading in stocks. Trade Brains Technologies Private Limited or the author are not liable for any losses caused as a result of the decision based on this article. Please consult your investment advisor before investing.

The post Privatisation: What Would Happen If Private Companies Ran Indian Railways? appeared first on Trade Brains.